Chanukah (Dedication)
CHANUKAH: THE HOLIDAY OF DEDICATION
The story of Chanukah does not appear in the Torah (the system of law described in 'the Book of the Law of Moses'), the 24 books of the Hebrew Bible (called by Christians as the 'Old Testament' and Judaism as the, "'Tanakh' [which] is an acronym of ... Torah ... Nevi'im (Prophets), and Ketuvim (Writings)" [1]) or standard versions of the New Testament. It does however appear in Books 1 and 2 of the Maccabees, which are included as part of the Catholic and Orthodox Christian Bibles [2].
Books of the Maccabees Excluded by Judaism
In last year's IsraelAlia post on Chanukah [3], I noted there was, "considerable debate as to why the Books of the Maccabees were excluded by ancient Jewish scholars".
This year I can see more clearly that this requires some consideration since Modern Judaism is clearly 'observing the appointed time' [4] of this Priest-ordained holiday every year.
The Story Behind Chanukah
In 1 Maccabees 1:20-21, we are told:
"In the year 143 ... Antiochus marched with a great army against the land of Israel and the city of Jerusalem. In his arrogance, he entered the Temple and took away the gold altar [and] the lampstand with all its equipment" [5].
1 Maccabees describes the heroic actions of valiant Israelites (including Priest Mattathias and his son, Judas Maccabeus, also a Priest) who stood up to and defeated the vast armies of King Antiochus against all odds. Judas Maccabeus then ordered the Temple be purified and rededicated (1 Maccabees 4:36; Maccabees 4:49-50 [6]).The celebration that has come to be known as 'Chanukah' is then described in 1 Maccabees 4:54-59:
"The 25th day of the 9th month, the month of Kislev in the year 148, was the anniversary of the [desecration of] the altar ... The new altar was dedicated and hymns were sung to the accompaniment of harps, lutes, and cymbals ... With great joy they brought burnt offerings and offered fellowship offerings and thank offerings ... For eight days they celebrated the rededication of the altar ... Then Judas, his brothers and the entire community of Israel decreed that the rededication of the altar should be celebrated with a festival of joy and gladness at the same time each year, beginning on the 25th of the month of Kislev and lasting for eight days".
The word 'chanukah' itself means 'rededication' [7].
Observations on 'Dedication'
Last year, I discussed the power held exclusively by priests to declare religious practices outside of what is written directly in the Torah (the Law of Moses). It was noted that the practice of lighting candles has come from the Oral Torah only (the collection of writings compiled by the Pharisees after they took over control from the Priestly Sadducees) and is not a law made by Priests (and Judges [8]).
This year I noticed a new interesting point. There is no law of the Torah that says Torah-observant Israelites [9] should be faithful to Y-hova [10] to the 'point of death'. This concept does however appear as a statement of what the Israelites did in practice in 1 Maccabees 1:62-63 [11]:
"But many people in Israel firmly resisted the king's decree and refused to eat food that was ritually unclean. They preferred to die rather than break the holy covenant and eat unclean food- and many did die".
Last year I noted that Jesus was recorded as celebrating the Feast of Dedication in John 10:22 [12] and this year I noticed that a few passages before, in John 10:6-18 [13], Jesus presents one of his parables where he mentions the practice of the 'Good Shepherd' laying down his life for his sheep.Laying one's life down for Y-hova (like the Maccabees) and laying down one's life for the people (like the Good Shepherd) are different but, as someone channelling the power of Y-hova so profoundly, Jesus' relationship to the law is extremely interesting.
I do think an under-recognised fact is that Jesus had been teaching on the Sabbath (Luke 6:6) [14] and also walking out in the fields on the Sabbath (Luke 6:1) [15], when Sabbath laws require us to rest on this day and remain in our dwelling places (Leviticus 23:3; Exodus 16:29) [16]. Y-hova's support of Jesus in his decision to heal on the Sabbath, on the very same occasion he had been out in the synagogue teaching, is manifest from the fact that a sick man's hand was ultimately healed at Jesus' word (Luke 6:10) [17] and the Pharisees persecuting him were put to shame by Y-hova. This, however, may have been more a demonstration of the passage in Psalms 124:2-3 that, 'had not Y-hova been on our side when people attacked us ... they would have swallowed us alive' [18]. Of course, the Pharisees themselves were also away from their dwelling places at the time, on the basis that the Oral Torah entitled them to do so.
Conclusion
The Maccabees were not prepared to eat even food Y-hova had declared unclean because their 'dedication' to Y-hova was so strong [19].
Chag Sameach!! Happy Holidays!!!
References
- Sefaria.org, 'About Tanakh': https://www.sefaria.org/texts/Tanakh.
- See for example, the Revised Standard Version - Catholic Edition: https://mycatholic.life/bible/rsvce/
- Last year's IsraelAlia post on Chanukah: https://web.facebook.com/IsraelAliaCovenant/photos/4118673968147931. The Pharisees may have downplayed the concept of standing up to enemies because one is not fully able to stand up to enemies without the real Torah as the source of strength. See also Note 8 below.
- The keeping of appointed times within the Torah ('moed'): https://biblehub.com/nasec/hebrew/4150.htm
- 1 Maccabees: https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=1%20Maccabees%201&version=GNT&fbclid=IwAR1WnpHqWg5uKQ6XS2Ol6jWYHMukQ1I6IUbkiwjmCrjgBj0qSWNV81gdXIw. 1 Maccabees 33-64: "33 Antiochus and his forces built high walls and strong towers in the area north of the Temple, turning it into a fort. 34 They brought in a group of traitorous Jews and installed them there. 36 The fort was a threat to the Temple, a constant, evil menace for Israel. 37 Innocent people were murdered around the altar; the Holy Place was defiled by murderers. 38 The people of Jerusalem fled in fear, and the city became a colony of foreigners. Jerusalem was foreign to its own people, who had been forced to abandon the city. 54 On the fifteenth day of the month of Kislev in the year 145, King Antiochus set up 'The Awful Horror' on the altar of the Temple, and pagan altars were built in the towns throughout Judea. 55 Pagan sacrifices were offered in front of houses and in the streets. 56 Any books of the Law which were found were torn up and burned, 57 and anyone who was caught with a copy of the sacred books or who obeyed the Law was put to death by order of the king. 58 Month after month these wicked people used their power against the Israelites caught in the towns. 59 On the twenty-fifth of the month, these same evil people offered sacrifices on the pagan altar erected on top of the altar in the Temple. 62 But many people in Israel firmly resisted the king's decree and refused to eat food that was ritually unclean. 63 They preferred to die rather than break the holy covenant and eat unclean food-and many did die. 64 In his anger God made Israel suffer terribly".
- 1 Maccabees 4: https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=1+Maccabees+4&version=GNT.
- See 'chanukah': https://biblehub.com/hebrew/2598.htm.
- "Priests and Judges had been fulfilling legal functions in ancient times. However, the Priestly system began to break down in approximately 160BC. The Sadducean priestly class started to introduce secular philosophies belonging to their Hellenistic aristocratic colleagues. Although the Pharisees were not priests, they were not prepared to let the Sadducees distort the religion. When the Sadducean Priesthood eventually fell apart, the Pharisaic Rabbis replaced the Priests in the interpretation, explanation, creation and application of Jewish law. The Pharisaic tradition of legal administration has continued right up to the present day and is known as Orthodox Rabbinic Judaism. The Sadducees simply disappeared with the passage of time" see: IsraelAlia, 'Summary' (updated): https://www.israelalia.com/summary/.
- The title 'Jew' refers essentially these days to the philosophical 'descendants' of the Pharisaic school. As Note 8 directly above explains, IsraelAlia is of the view that Phariseeism was a temporary phase only and is not in fact an accurate reflection of the Torah system. The religion discussed by IsraelAlia is more a 'mirror-image reflection' of the Torah (as practiced in ancient times). See, IsraelAlia, 'Theory in Detail' (updated): https://www.israelalia.com/theory-detail/.
- For why I write Y-hova's name as I do, see: https://www.israelalia.com/g-ds-name/.
- 1 Maccabees: https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=1%20Maccabees%201&version=GNT&fbclid=IwAR1WnpHqWg5uKQ6XS2Ol6jWYHMukQ1I6IUbkiwjmCrjgBj0qSWNV81gdXIw.
- John 10:22: https://biblehub.com/interlinear/john/10-22.htm.
- See John 10: https://biblehub.com/bsb/john/10.htm.
- Luke 6:6: https://biblehub.com/luke/6-6.htm. See also Luke 6: https://biblehub.com/bsb/luke/6.htm.
- Luke 6:1: https://biblehub.com/luke/6-1.htm.
- Exodus 16:29: https://biblehub.com/interlinear/exodus/16-29.htm.
- Luke 6:10: https://biblehub.com/luke/6-10.htm.
- Psalms 124: https://biblehub.com/bsb/psalms/124.htm.
- Please note, the concept of 'dedication' to a cause and 'dedication' of a temple are technically separate!